You May Like
🚨😱 THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 HUTCHISON-CATES 616 A Variant LTD 750 Scream
$19.99
View Details
KISS ME SATAN 2 NM BARNABUS BLACK HORROR DARK HORSE COMICS 2014
$2.95
View Details
🚨😱 THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 HUTCHISON-CATES 616 B Variant LTD 500 COA
$24.99
View Details
Rue Morgue magazine #89 VF/NM; Marrs Media Inc | Drag Me To Hell - we combine sh
$8.50
View Details
1988 Topps FRIGHT FLICKS Singles - YOU CHOOSE! Trading Cards Freddy Alien
$2.49
View Details
2023 Mark Pingitore Horrorible 8 Kids U Pick Complete Your Set Magic Marker GPK
$0.99
View Details
HOLLYWOOD ZOMBIES 2007 PICK-A-CARD BASE,FOIL,GLOW,BONUS,PROMO garbage pail kids
$5.99
View Details
Hellraiser 1992 Kneel Before Me Horror Card #90 (NM)
$2.95
View Details
Hellraiser 1992 Come To Me Horror Card #68 (NM)
$2.95
View Details
Obey Me! Art Collect Card - Choose Cards -
$14.99
View Details
CRAWL TO ME GRAPHIC NOVEL (NM) IDW HORROR, $3.95 FLAT RATE SHIPPING
$14.89
View Details
FOIL 2023 Mark Pingitore Horrorible Kids 8 U Pick Complete Your Set GPK FOIL
$2.99
View Details
The Me You Love In The Dark #1 Gold Foil Comic Vault Live Edition CVL CGC 9.8 NM
$49.99
View Details
Drag Me To Hell Platinum Plated Artist Signed “Horror Classic” Trading Card 1/1
$29.95
View Details
FOLLOW ME INTO DARKNESS #1 2 3 4 A CONNELLY & VARIANT SET 2022 BEHEMOTH LOT NM
$19.99
View Details
KISS ME SATAN 5 NM BARNABUS BLACK HORROR DARK HORSE COMICS 2014
$2.95
View Details
Pick Your Own 2023 Horrorible Kids Stickers All New Series 8 Base & Foil Cards
$1.99
View Details
🔥2007 Topps Hollywood Zombies YOU PICK & Complete Your Set! Mint! Trump,Hogan🔥
$0.99
View Details
1994 The Crow Official Movie Trading Cards / Brandon Lee / Choose / bx73
$1.17
View Details
2004 Comic Images Van Helsing Movie Base Cards #1-72 You Pick Buy 2 Get 2 Free!
$1.00
View Details
Hellraiser 1992 Help Me Horror Card #67 (NM)
$2.95
View Details
Tales From the Crypt 1993 Bug Me Card #32 (NM)
$2.95
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - MORGAN BEEM VIRGIN VARIANT!
$15.00
View Details
Little Shop of Horrors trading card stickers 1986 Topps Pick-A-Card You-Choose
$4.99
View Details
1992 FANGORIA horror magazine cards Splatter (you pick) Pack Fresh FREE SHIPPING
$3.95
View Details
1986 Topps Little Shop of Horrors #27 Feed Me!
$3.99
View Details
Drag Me to Hell Custom Novelty Movie Card
$5.95
View Details
Tales from the Crypt 1993 Cardz Bartender Give Me Another Shot
$5.95
View Details
American McGee's Alice, Small Box, Near Mint, WATA 9.4 A+
$599.95
View Details
🚨😱 THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 HUTCHISON-CATES 616 Variant Set LTD 500 COA
$39.99
View Details
2024 Garbage Pail Kids Oh Horror-ible GOLD FOIL Wrapper 14 TALK TO ME movie Card
$142.45
View Details
🚨😱 THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 HAL LAREN Exclusive Variant LTD 500
$19.99
View Details
2015 Garbage Pail Kids 30th Anniversary Horror Films The Fly Who Bugged Me 0ba6
$2.55
View Details
WRAPPER 2024 Garbage Pail Kids Oh the Horror-ible Finish Your Set U Pick SEPIA
$9.99
View Details
2023 Topps GARBAGE PAIL KIDS OH THE HORRIBLE Single Complete your setYOU-PICK-IT
$4.99
View Details
2021 IMAGE COMICS THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #4 NM HORROR Visit My eBay Store
$2.99
View Details
The Me You Love In The Dark #1 Gold Foil Comic Vault Live Edition CGC 9.8 NM
$29.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 HUTCHISON-CATES 616 A Variant LTD 750 Scream NM
$10.99
View Details
👻 SVENGOOLIE 45TH ANNIV BOO NANZA Buy Me Toys Mark Spears Exclusive
$69.88
View Details
You Promised Me Darkness #4B VF/NM; Behemoth | Damian Connelly - we combine ship
$3.75
View Details
YOU PROMISED ME DARKNESS (2021 BEHEMOTH COMICS) #1 D Connelly Variant NM Horror
$4.29
View Details
2023 HORRORIBLE KIDS NEW SERIES 8 TEDDY TOLD ME TO 262b MARK PINGITORE
$3.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1-A & TWIG #1-A SKOTTIE YOUNG SET IMAGE 9.4 NM
$7.99
View Details
1988 Fright Flicks #52 Nightmare On Elm Street III "When You Said You'd Have Me
$2.65
View Details
LONDON NIGHT STUDIOS EMBRACE KILL ME SOFTLY VOL. 1, #1 NOVEMBER 1996
$10.00
View Details
Tales From the Crypt 1993 Has Me Stumped Card #17 (NM)
$2.95
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - BIRD CITY ARIEL DIAZ VARIANT!
$20.00
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - JON LAM SKETCH VIRGIN VARIANT
$20.00
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - TFAW ERYK DONOVAN VARIANT!
$10.00
View Details
MTG Duskmourn - House of Horrors Oversized Archenemy Cards - Near Mint
$2.02
View Details
Asylum #1 (1993) VF+ NM- (9.0) Horror Short Stories/ Bolton Cover and Art
$2.75
View Details
8D6-2 1992 HELLRAISER Trading Card Singles NEW UNCIRCULATED Your Choice Quality
$1.99
View Details
Harry Potter Screen Used Relic Prop Card Gilderoy Lockhart's Magical Me Book
$90.00
View Details
YOU PROMISED ME DARKNESS (2021 BEHEMOTH COMICS) #1 C Connelly Variant NM Horror
$4.29
View Details
1986 Topps Little Shop of Horrors Stickers #27 Feed me!
$3.99
View Details
You Promised Me Darkness #1 (2021) CGC 9.8 John Gallagher Trade Press Variant
$39.99
View Details
MTG - (ADSC) Archenemy - Commander - Duskmourn: House of Horror Price Guide
$2.07
View Details
ALIENS DUST TO DUST #3, VF/NM, Monster and Me, 2018, more Horror in store
$6.99
View Details
Double Walker Tremor Dose Let Me In The Sickness Midnighter Black Star Above
$19.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - VALENTINE PASCHE VARIANT!
$10.00
View Details
LET ME IN #1 2 3 4, NM, Child Vampire with Man servant,2010,more HORROR in store
$44.99
View Details
Image Spawn - 1995 Wildstorm *BASE / CHASE / PROMO CARDS* NM-MT *PICK YOURS*
$1.25
View Details
Drag Me To Hell Limited Edition Artist Signed “Horror Classic” Trading Card 1/10
$19.95
View Details
2023 ZEROCOOL STRANGER THINGS SEASON 4 PICK-A-CARD BASE #1-#100 TOPPS NETFLIX
$0.99
View Details
1986 Topps Little Shop of Horrors #12 Feed Me!
$3.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 2ND PRINT B&W VARIANT 2021 IMAGE COMICS NM
$2.49
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - NM - GALLAGHER VIRGIN VARIANT! SIGNED🔥
$30.00
View Details
Tales from the Crypt 1993 Cardz This One Has Me Stumped Card
$5.95
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK (2021 Image Comics) #1 NM SKOTTIE YOUNG Horror 🔥🔥
$3.99
View Details
YOU PROMISED ME DARKNESS #1A Sebastian cover + #1B Comics HORROR Behemoth Comics
$24.95
View Details
1989 topps batman #44 the joker RC wait’ll they get a load of me PSA 8 NM/MT
$33.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #2 (2021) - GRADE NM - 2ND PRINTING - 1:20 VARIANT!
$15.00
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #2 (2021) - GRADE NM - ZU ORZU BLACK CAPE VARIANT!
$10.00
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 SKOTTIE YOUNG EXCLUSIVE VARIANT Image Comic
$29.99
View Details
2024 GPK OH THE HORROR-IBLE WRAPPERS B & W- U PICK Complete Your Set
$8.99
View Details
1980 Topps You'll Die Laughing Creature Feature # 42 Who Sold Me That Hair (NM)
$2.95
View Details
PICK A CARD! Garbage Pail Kids Go On Vacation Don't Make Me Pull This Car Over
$1.49
View Details
Jb10d Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 2 Two #21 Spike Drusilla Lie To Me
$1.99
View Details
Jb10d Buffy The Vampire Slayer Season 2 Two #20 Spike Willow Lie To Me
$1.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - GRADE NM - ERICA WILLEY VIRGIN VARIANT!
$25.00
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 - NM (Unread Copy)
$45.00
View Details
MOTU ORIGINS HORRORS PIG HEAD WORDLESS MASTERS UNIVERSE GIVEAWAY PROMO MINI 2022
$6.99
View Details
PICK A CARD! Garbage Pail Kids Go On Vacation Don't Make Me Pull This Car Over
$1.99
View Details
The Shirelles 1966 Heather Pop Music ROOKIE CARD Will You Love Me Tomorrow
$19.99
View Details
Kiss Me, Satan! #1-5 VF/NM complete series - New Orleans Werewolf - Dark Horse
$5.98
View Details
Garbage Pail Kids TALK TO MIA 2024 Oh the Horror-Ible 14a Talk To Me GPK
$6.00
View Details
2023 Zerocool Stranger Things Season 4 - Base, Parallel & Insert Cards - U Pick!
$1.99
View Details
Spawn Widevision Cards ~ 1995 WildStorm ~ Todd McFarlane ~ You Pick The Cards!
$1.25
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #3 (2021) - GRADE NM - ZU ORZU VIRGIN VARIANT!
$30.00
View Details
Kiss Me, Satan #1 VF/NM; Dark Horse | we combine shipping
$2.49
View Details
Mark Spears Monsters Halloween Edition /99 Bloody Fear Me #17
$3.24
View Details
LONDON NIGHT STUDIOS EMBRACE KILL ME SOFTLY VOL. 1, #1 NOVEMBER 1996 (NM)
$19.50
View Details
2023 Zerocool Stranger Things Season 4 Trading Cards Base Parallels Inserts
$4.49
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #2 (2021) - GRADE NM - ZU ORZU VIRGIN VARIANT!
$25.00
View Details
2023 Upper Deck LOKI Green Foil Base Card #62 You're Gonna Tell Me Everything
$1.49
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #1 (2021) - NM - RYAN G BROWNE VIRGIN VARIANT!
$14.99
View Details
THE ME YOU LOVE IN THE DARK #5 (2021) - GRADE NM - ZU ORZU VIRGIN VARIANT!
$30.00
View Details
* Murder Me Dead # 9 * GRUESOME HORROR COVER! El Capitan … David Lapham … NM 9.4
$1.99
View Details
Me You Love in the Dark #1 Suspirialand Exclusive Variant Cover CGC 9.8.
$179.99
View Details
YOU PROMISED ME DARKNESS # 1 (2021) — Cover G Variant Behemoth Comics HOT — NM
$15.99
View Details